Jenna has returned, but she’s not the same girl she was when she left. Her favorite color has gone from pink to black; she wears her hair differently, and prefers reading The Chronicles instead of the latest clothing catalog. Her parents have trouble adjusting to Jenna’s newly formed personality, and all the while Jenna begins to realize that she hadn’t gone insane during her first day back at Forest Grove High. Everything seems to go smoothly at first. Jenna reunites with her Roxi, her best friend and she resumes her class schedule as planned until, Justin Wallace returns to school. But he’s not the same Justin he was before. Something happened to him that night that neither Jenna nor her friends could have imagined. He’s different; very different, and he’s looking for revenge. Can Jenna earn his forgiveness and save her friends from his wrath in the process?